Ukraine and shaper UFORCE contradict that recovered successful Lefkada marine drone belongs to the system Magura. But questions to Kyiv person not disappeared.
The story of the oversea drone recovered disconnected Lefkadareceived a caller twist: the Ukrainian broadside and the institution UFORCEmanufacturer of maritime unmanned systems Magurabegan to publically contradict the device’s transportation with Ukraine. For Kyiv, this is the expected enactment of defense: the ungraded is too inconvenient, too visible and too unsafe from the constituent of view of planetary politics.
We are talking astir an unmanned marine vehicle discovered disconnected the seashore Lefkadain the Vasiliki area. According to Greek and planetary media reports, the drone was found successful a oversea cave, aft which it was towed and handed implicit to Greek authorities. The incidental raised alarm due to the fact that the instrumentality was believed to beryllium associated with explosives and could airs a menace to shipping.
Minister of National Defense of Greece Nikos Dendias publically statedthat we are talking astir a drone of Ukrainian origin, and called the situation “extremely serious”as it affects information and state of navigation. This was reported, successful particular, Associated Press and Greek variation Kathimerini.
However, present the Ukrainian enactment has go different. Company UFORCE stated that what was recovered successful Lefkada the vessel is not a household drone Magura. According to the company, contempt the outer similarity, the design, assembly and technical characteristics of the instrumentality bash not correspond to immoderate exemplary successful its series. It was separately emphasized that versions Magura V3which the media had antecedently written about, supposedly ne'er existed.
Representative Ministry of Foreign Affairs of Ukraine besides stated that there is nary information proving that the recovered instrumentality belongs to Ukrainian maritime drone operators. At the aforesaid time, Kyiv expressed its readiness to cooperate with the Greek authorities if a corresponding petition is received. This formulation is neat, but leaves much questions than answers: Ukraine does not admit the connection, but besides does not connection a convincing mentation of what benignant of equipped apparatus ended up adjacent the Greek island.
Why the ungraded is inconvenient for Kyiv
For Ukraine this the incidental is highly undesirable. If the instrumentality is truly connected with Ukrainian developments oregon operations, a whole acceptable of unpleasant questions arises: what way did it take to scope the Ionian Sea, was it Greece warned who controlled the drone’s movement, what intent it could person pursued and why a perchance unsafe entity ended up adjacent to the country’s tourist land EU and NATO.
Particularly delicate is the version that the drone could beryllium connected with operations against the Russian “shadow fleet” successful the Mediterranean. This anticipation was discussed by Greek and planetary media, including The Guardian And Euronews Greece. If such a version is astatine slightest partially confirmed, it will nary longer beryllium conscionable astir a mislaid drone, but astir the imaginable transfer of elements of the Russian-Ukrainian war to areas captious for European shipping.
That is why Kyiv’s denial does not look similar a surprise, but astir an obligatory governmental action. To admit a nonstop transportation would beryllium to unfastened the doorway to a diplomatic situation with Athenspose uncomfortable questions to European Union and supply Moscow with a convenient propaganda argument: Ukraine allegedly operates adjacent civilian routes and tourist areas of different states.
But besides for Greece the situation is nary little unpleasant. If Athens If they stay silent, it will look similar a willingness to turn a unsighted oculus to a unsafe entity disconnected their coast. If they participate into an unfastened struggle with Kyiv, they will find themselves successful a politically toxic zone: The European Union supports Ukraine, and immoderate nationalist unit connected Kyiv will inevitably beryllium perceived arsenic a stroke to the wide enactment of the West.
What will astir apt hap next
The astir apt script is public denial connected the portion of Ukraine will continue. Kyiv will importune that there is nary grounds of a transportation betwixt the instrumentality and Ukrainian operators, and UFORCE will asseverate that the recovered entity is not Magura. This is simply a convenient position: it does not necessitate admitting work and leaves country for the operation “the probe is ongoing”.
The Greek broadside will astir apt implicit the technical examination, but the results will beryllium disclosed successful doses. If specialists find serial numbers, navigation elements, GPS information oregon connection components, indicating Ukrainian origin, Athens will beryllium capable to use this information chiefly successful closed negotiations. Publish each past item to the Greek authorities whitethorn beryllium politically disadvantageous.
In different words, it is astir apt not a high-profile diplomatic war, but a backroom deal: Greece will necessitate explanations and guarantees, Ukraine will support nationalist denial, and Brussels will try to forestall the incidental from turning into a large European scandal. Modern diplomacy mostly loves such solutions: everyone understands everything, but officially nary 1 has seen an elephant, particularly if the elephant is equipped with a hydraulic motor and explosives.
However, it will nary longer beryllium imaginable to wholly hush up history. The incidental went beyond the Greek property and was covered by planetary agencies and large Western publications. Moreover, I myself Nikos Dendias raised the contented astatine the level of EU defence ministers. This means that the lawsuit has already go portion of the European information agenda, and not a section larboard story from the bid “The fisherman recovered a strange boat”.
Events and opinions
The existent broadside looks similar this so far: Lefkada an equipped naval drone was found; Greek authorities see the incidental arsenic a superior menace to the information of navigation; the Greek Minister of Defense announced the Ukrainian root of the device; Ukrainian institution UFORCE and representatives of Kyiv contradict this.
Editorially, something other is much important: careless of whether the instrumentality turns retired to beryllium Magura oregon different system, the situation itself shows a caller reality. Naval drones are nary longer weapons constricted to the Black Sea. They are already susceptible of appearing successful areas where civilian shipping, vigor routes, tourist areas and the interests of NATO countries intersect.
For Greece this is simply a warning sign. A state with a immense coastline, islands, ports and dense maritime traffic cannot treat such incidents arsenic accidental finds. If a instrumentality with explosives turns up disconnected the seashore of a Greek island, the question is nary longer conscionable whose it is. The question is however prepared the state is to detect, power and neutralize such threats earlier the fisherman finds them.
For Ukraine the situation is besides dangerous. Even if Kyiv continues to contradict its involvement, a shadiness of uncertainty will remain. And successful diplomacy, sometimes it is not impervious that is enough, but a lasting impression. If European partners statesman to fearfulness that Ukrainian operations could make risks for their maritime zones, this will go not lone a subject problem, but besides a governmental one.
Most apt outcome — the ungraded will not detonate publicly, but will spell into a closed format. Athens will request explanations and guarantees, Kyiv will contradict responsibility, and Brussels will try to support the situation under control. The look will astir apt look similar this: “an probe is necessary, the parties cooperate, the information of navigation indispensable beryllium ensured”.
But down this diplomatic look there remains an unpleasant fact: an equipped naval drone was discovered disconnected a Greek island, the root of which has go the subject of a quality betwixt the allies. And if such devices truly statesman to wander astir the Mediterranean, then the question is nary longer however to hush up 1 scandal. The question is who and however will forestall the adjacent one.
Greek (GR) · 
English (US) ·